Skip to Main content

  • Shelly Pie

Shelly Pie 912 PENN AVE

912 PENN AVE, Turtle Creek, PA
Pickup Only
‌
‌
Food Menu
Merchandise

Featured Items

  • Wedding Soup

    $5.50+

  • Chicken Wings

    $9.99+

  • Lasagna

    $17.99

Food Menu

Appetizers

  • Banana Peppers Oil & Garlic

    $10.50

  • Bread Sticks

    $8.50+

  • Buffalo Cheese Fries

    $10.50

  • Chili Cheese Fries

    $11.50

  • Cinnamon Sugar Knots

    $3.50+

  • Parm Garlic Fries

    $10.50

  • Garlic Knots

    $3.50+

  • Italian Greens & Beans

    $10.25

  • Pizza Potato Skins

    $10.50

  • Polenta Asiago

    $9.99

  • Pub Pretzels

    $9.50

  • Regular Potato Skins

    $10.50

  • Stuffed Banana Peppers

    $10.50

  • Basket of Chips

    $5.99

  • Breaded Mushrooms

    $8.25

  • Broccoli Chedder Puffs

    $8.25

  • Chicken Finger Basket

    $11.25

  • Chicken Wings

    $9.99+

  • Clam Basket

    $11.25

  • French Fries

    $4.25+

  • Fried Pickles

    $8.25

  • Hot Pepper Cheese Balls

    $8.25

  • Onion Rings

    $8.75

  • Provolone Sticks

    $8.99

  • Shrimp Basket

    $11.25

  • Zuchini Planks

    $10.75

Soups & Salads

  • Tossed Salad

    $6.50

  • Family Size Tossed Salad

    $16.50

  • Antipasta Salad

    $13.99

  • Family Sized Antipasta Salad

    $21.99

  • Chef Salad

    $13.99

  • Family Sized Chef Salad

    $21.99

  • Turkey Club Salad

    $13.99

  • Family Sized Turkey Bacon Club Salad

    $21.99

  • Chicken Salad

    $14.50

  • Steak Salad

    $16.75

  • Wedding Soup

    $5.50+

  • Soup of the day

    $5.50+

  • Chili

    $5.75+

  • Soup Flights (dine in only)

    $11.50

Burgers & Sandwiches

  • 1/2 Pound Burger

    $12.75

  • Maddie Mac

    $13.75

  • Patty Melt

    $13.99

  • American Club

    $13.00

  • Italian Club

    $13.00

  • Turkey & Bacon Club

    $13.00

  • Roast Beef Bacon Club

    $13.00

  • Chicken Parm Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Eggplant Parm Hoagie

    $8.75+

  • Hot Sausage Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Italian Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Magoo Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Meatball Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Steak Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Turkey Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Veggie Hoagie

    $8.50+

  • BLT

    $10.99

  • Chicken Sand

    $13.00

  • Fish Sandwich

    $14.99

  • Grilled Cheese

    $8.75

  • Hot Meatloaf

    OUT OF STOCK
    $12.75

  • Hot Roast Beef

    $12.75

  • Hot Turkey

    $12.75

  • Rachel

    $12.99

  • Reuben

    $12.99

  • Tuna Melt

    $11.99

Entrees

  • Cheese Ravioli

    $15.25

  • Chicken Finger Dinner

    $15.50

  • Chicken Marsala

    $15.50+

  • Chicken Parmesan

    $15.50+

  • Chicken Picatta

    $15.50+

  • Eggplant Parmesan

    $15.50

  • Fettuccini Alfredo

    $15.25

  • Gluten Friendly Pasta Marinara

    $13.95

  • Gnocchi

    $15.25

  • Grilled Chicken Breast

    $14.50+

  • Lasagna

    $17.99

  • Liver & Onions

    $12.99

  • Meatball Parmesan

    $16.50

  • Pasta Arrabiata

    $14.25

  • Pasta Bolognese

    $15.50

  • Pasta Marinara

    $14.25

  • Pasta O & G

    $14.25

  • Pasta with Homemade Tomato Sauce

    $14.25

  • Shrimp Scampi

    $21.00

  • Stuffed Shells

    $15.50

Pizza & Shellzones

  • Mini (4 cut)

    $7.99

  • Small (6 cut)

    $12.50

  • Medium (8 cut)

    $14.50

  • Large (12 cut)

    $16.50

  • Sicilian Mini

    $7.99

  • Sicilian Small

    $14.75

  • Sicilian Large

    $20.75

  • Mini Buffalo

    $10.74

  • Small Buffalo Chicken

    $16.25

  • Medium Buffalo Chicken

    $18.75

  • Large Buffalo Chicken

    $21.25

  • Mini BBQ

    $10.74

  • Small BBQ Chicken

    $16.25

  • Medium BBQ Chicken

    $18.75

  • Large BBQ Chicken

    $21.25

  • Mini EBUT

    $17.99

  • Small EBUT

    $28.75

  • Medium EBUT

    $33.25

  • Large EBUT

    $37.75

  • Mini Hawaiian

    $12.49

  • Small Hawaiian

    $19.00

  • Medium Hawaiian

    $22.00

  • Large Hawaiian

    $25.00

  • Mini Tom & Spin

    $12.49

  • Small Tom & Spin

    $19.00

  • Medium Tom & Spin

    $22.00

  • Large Tom & Spin

    $25.00

  • Mini Special Blue

    $15.74

  • Small Special Blue

    $23.25

  • Medium Special Bleu

    $26.75

  • Large Special Bleu

    $30.25

  • Mini Buffalo Chicken Sicilian

    $10.24

  • Small Buffalo Chicken Sicilian

    $17.50

  • Large Buffalo Chicken Sicilian

    $25.50

  • Mini BBQ Chix Sicilian

    $10.24

  • Small BBQ Chx Sicilian

    $17.50

  • Large BBQ Chicken Sicilian

    $22.24

  • Mini EBUT Sicilian

    $17.99

  • Small EBUT Sicilian

    $27.25

  • Large EBUT Sicilian

    $35.24

  • Mini Hawaiian Sicilian

    $11.99

  • Small Hawaiian Sicilian

    $19.75

  • Large Hawaiian Sicilian

    $25.50

  • Mini Tom & Spin Sicilian

    $11.99

  • Small Tom & Spin Sicilian

    $19.75

  • Large Tom & Spin Sicilian

    $25.50

  • Mini Special Bleu Sicilian

    $14.49

  • Small Special Bleu Sicilian

    $22.75

  • Large Special Bleu Sicilian

    $28.49

  • *GLUTEN FREE* Pizza

    $12.99

  • SHELLZONE

    $13.50

  • Small

    $3.00

  • Medium

    $4.00

  • Large

    $5.00

Daily Specials

  • Breaded Cheese Curds

    $8.25

  • Bruschetta

    $7.99

  • Chicken Bruschetta Pasta

    $16.99

  • gyro pasta

    $16.99

  • 1 piece hawaiian pork chops

    $13.99

  • 2 piece hawaiian pork chops

    $17.99

  • 10 oz. grilled ribeye

    $20.99

  • Mini Sicilian Combo

    $10.74

  • Mini Pizza Combo

    $10.74

  • mini italian hoagie pizza

    $14.99

  • maddie mac salad

    $13.50

  • bowl hot banana pepper

    $6.50

  • bowl chicken noodle

    $6.50

  • cup hot banana pepper

    $5.50

  • cup chicken noodle

    $5.50

NA Beverages

  • 16 oz Bottle

    $1.50

  • 20 oz Bottle

    $2.00

  • 2 LT MT Dew

    $3.50

  • 2 LT Pepsi

    $3.50

  • 2 LT Diet Pepsi

    $3.50

  • 2 LTCherry pepsi

    $3.50

  • 2 LT Ginger ale

    $3.50

  • 20oz Pepsi

    $2.50

  • 24oz Pepsi

    $2.75

  • Bottled Water

    $1.00

  • Can Diet Dew

    $1.25

  • Can Diet Pepsi

    $1.25

  • Can Mt Dew

    $1.25

  • Can Pepsi

    $1.25

  • Red Bull

    $3.50

  • Starbucks Frap

    $3.25

  • Can dr. Pepper

    $1.25

  • Can ginger ale

    $1.25

  • Can root beer

    $1.25

  • Can Coca cola

    $1.25

  • Can Poppi

    $1.75

  • sm gat aids

    $1.25

  • lg gat aids

    $1.75

  • Liquid Ice

    $3.50

  • Gal Diet Iced Tea

    $4.00

  • Gal Reg Iced Tea

    $4.00

  • QRT Black & Gold

    $2.00

  • QRT Diet Iced Tea

    $2.00

  • QRT Reg Iced Tea

    $2.00

  • Lemonade

    $1.25

  • Diet Tea

    $1.25

  • Reg Tea

    $1.25

Kids

  • Mac & Cheese

    $6.99

  • Kids Chicken Finger

    $6.99

  • Kids Pasta w/ MB

    $6.99

  • Kid Pizza

    $6.99

  • Kids Burger

    $6.99

  • Kids Rav

    $6.99

  • Kids Grilled Cheese

    $6.99

Desserts

  • Carrot Cake

    $7.99

  • Cheesecake

    $8.99

  • Chocolate Cake

    $7.99

  • Cin Pretzel Bites

    $5.99

  • Funnel Cake Fries

    $7.95

  • funnel cake sundae

    $5.99

  • lemon bliss cheesecake

    $8.99

Sides & Extras

  • 12 oz dressing

    $4.50

  • 3 Garlic Bread

    $2.50

  • 6 Garlic Bread

    $4.50

  • 8 oz dressing

    $3.00

  • add egg

    $1.25

  • Apple sauce

    $4.25

  • Bacon

    $2.00

  • Beef Gravy

    $0.75

  • Cheese Sauce

    $1.99

  • Chicken Gravy

    $0.75

  • Coleslaw

    $4.25

  • Crumbled Bleu

    $1.99

  • Extra bread

    $0.50

  • Extra Chicken Breast

    $5.00

  • Extra cocktail

    $0.75

  • Extra Lg dressing

    $1.05

  • Extra Meat sauce

    $2.00

  • Extra Meatball

    $2.75

  • Extra sauce

    $1.05

  • Extra sausage

    $3.00

  • Extra Shrimp

    $8.00

  • Extra Sm dressing

    $0.75

  • Extra Steak

    $7.00

  • Extra tartar

    $0.75

  • Garlic butter Lg

    $1.05

  • Garlic butter Sm

    $0.75

  • Mac & cheese

    $6.50

  • Mashed

    $4.25

  • Quart of dressing

    $12.00

  • Shredded Cheese

    $1.99

  • Side of pasta

    $6.50

  • Veg of day

    $4.25

Merchandise

Keychain

  • Keychain

    $5.00

T Shirts

  • Womens Medium

    $20.00

  • Womens Large

    $20.00

  • Womens X Large

    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.00

  • Mens Large

    $20.00

  • Mens XLarge

    $20.00

  • Mens XXLarge

    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.00
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 2.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Extra sausage

$3.00
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Shelly Pie Location and Hours

(412) 646-2560
912 PENN AVE, Turtle Creek, PA 15145
Open now • Closes at 11PM
View menu
Facebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement