Skip to Main content

  • Shelly Pie

Shelly Pie 912 PENN AVE

912 PENN AVE, Turtle Creek, PA
Pickup Only
‌
‌
Food Menu
Merchandise

Featured Items

  • Wedding Soup

    $5.50+

  • Chicken Wings

    $9.99+

  • Lasagna

    $17.99

Food Menu

Appetizers

  • Banana Peppers Oil & Garlic

    $10.50

  • Bread Sticks

    $8.50+

  • Buffalo Cheese Fries

    $10.50

  • Chili Cheese Fries

    $11.50

  • Parm Garlic Fries

    $10.50

  • Italian Greens & Beans

    $10.25

  • Pizza Potato Skins

    $10.50

  • Polenta Asiago

    $9.99

  • Regular Potato Skins

    $10.50

  • Stuffed Banana Peppers

    $10.50

  • Basket of Chips

    $5.99

  • Breaded Mushrooms

    $8.25

  • Broccoli Chedder Puffs

    $8.25

  • Chicken Finger Basket

    $11.25

  • Chicken Wings

    $9.99+

  • Clam Basket

    $11.25

  • French Fries

    $4.25+

  • Fried Pickles

    $8.25

  • Garlic Knots

    $3.50+

  • Hot Pepper Cheese Balls

    $8.25

  • Onion Rings

    $8.75

  • Provolone Sticks

    $8.99

  • Pub Pretzels

    $9.50

  • Shrimp Basket

    $11.25

  • Zuchini Planks

    $10.75

Soups & Salads

  • Tossed Salad

    $6.50

  • Family Size Tossed Salad

    $16.50

  • Antipasta Salad

    $13.99

  • Family Sized Antipasta Salad

    $21.99

  • Chef Salad

    $13.99

  • Family Sized Chef Salad

    $21.99

  • Turkey Club Salad

    $13.99

  • Family Sized Turkey Bacon Club Salad

    $21.99

  • Chicken Salad

    $14.50

  • Steak Salad

    $16.75

  • Wedding Soup

    $5.50+

  • Soup of the day

    $5.50+

  • Chili

    $5.75+

  • Soup Flights (dine in only)

    $11.50

Burgers & Sandwiches

  • 1/2 Pound Burger

    $12.75

  • Maddie Mac

    $13.75

  • Patty Melt

    $13.99

  • American Club

    $13.00

  • Italian Club

    $13.00

  • Turkey & Bacon Club

    $13.00

  • Roast Beef Bacon Club

    $13.00

  • Chicken Parm Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Eggplant Parm Hoagie

    $8.75+

  • Hot Sausage Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Italian Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Magoo Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Meatball Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Steak Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Turkey Hoagie

    $9.75+

  • Veggie Hoagie

    $8.50+

  • BLT

    $10.99

  • Chicken Sand

    $13.00

  • Fish Sandwich

    $14.99

  • Grilled Cheese

    $8.75

  • Hot Meatloaf

    $12.75

  • Hot Roast Beef

    $12.75

  • Hot Turkey

    $12.75

  • Rachel

    $12.99

  • Reuben

    $12.99

  • Tuna Melt

    $11.99

Entrees

  • Cheese Ravioli

    $15.25

  • Chicken Finger Dinner

    $15.50

  • Chicken Marsala

    $15.50+

  • Chicken Parmesan

    $15.50+

  • Chicken Picatta

    $15.50+

  • Eggplant Parmesan

    $15.50

  • Fettuccini Alfredo

    $15.25

  • Gluten Friendly Pasta Marinara

    $13.95

  • Gnocchi

    $15.25

  • Grilled Chicken Breast

    $14.50+

  • Lasagna

    $17.99

  • Liver & Onions

    $12.99

  • Meatball Parmesan

    $16.50

  • Pasta Arrabiata

    $14.25

  • Pasta Bolognese

    $15.50

  • Pasta Marinara

    $14.25

  • Pasta O & G

    $14.25

  • Pasta with Homemade Tomato Sauce

    $14.25

  • Shrimp Scampi

    $21.00

  • Stuffed Shells

    $15.50

Pizza & Shellzones

  • Mini (4 cut)

    $7.99

  • Small (6 cut)

    OUT OF STOCK
    $12.50

  • Medium (8 cut)

    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.50

  • Large (12 cut)

    OUT OF STOCK
    $16.50

  • Sicilian Mini

    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.99

  • Sicilian Small

    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.75

  • Sicilian Large

    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.75

  • Mini Buffalo

    OUT OF STOCK
    $10.74

  • Small Buffalo Chicken

    OUT OF STOCK
    $16.25

  • Medium Buffalo Chicken

    OUT OF STOCK
    $18.75

  • Large Buffalo Chicken

    OUT OF STOCK
    $21.25

  • Mini BBQ

    OUT OF STOCK
    $10.74

  • Small BBQ Chicken

    OUT OF STOCK
    $16.25

  • Medium BBQ Chicken

    OUT OF STOCK
    $18.75

  • Large BBQ Chicken

    OUT OF STOCK
    $21.25

  • Mini EBUT

    OUT OF STOCK
    $17.99

  • Small EBUT

    OUT OF STOCK
    $28.75

  • Medium EBUT

    OUT OF STOCK
    $33.25

  • Large EBUT

    OUT OF STOCK
    $37.75

  • Mini Hawaiian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $12.49

  • Small Hawaiian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $19.00

  • Medium Hawaiian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.00

  • Large Hawaiian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.00

  • Mini Tom & Spin

    OUT OF STOCK
    $12.49

  • Small Tom & Spin

    OUT OF STOCK
    $19.00

  • Medium Tom & Spin

    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.00

  • Large Tom & Spin

    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.00

  • Mini Special Blue

    OUT OF STOCK
    $15.74

  • Small Special Blue

    OUT OF STOCK
    $23.25

  • Medium Special Bleu

    OUT OF STOCK
    $26.75

  • Large Special Bleu

    OUT OF STOCK
    $30.25

  • Mini Buffalo Chicken Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $10.24

  • Small Buffalo Chicken Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $17.50

  • Large Buffalo Chicken Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.50

  • Mini BBQ Chix Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $10.24

  • Small BBQ Chx Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $17.50

  • Large BBQ Chicken Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.24

  • Mini EBUT Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $17.99

  • Small EBUT Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $27.25

  • Large EBUT Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $35.24

  • Mini Hawaiian Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $11.99

  • Small Hawaiian Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $19.75

  • Large Hawaiian Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.50

  • Mini Tom & Spin Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $11.99

  • Small Tom & Spin Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $19.75

  • Large Tom & Spin Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $25.50

  • Mini Special Bleu Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.49

  • Small Special Bleu Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.75

  • Large Special Bleu Sicilian

    OUT OF STOCK
    $28.49

  • *GLUTEN FREE* Pizza

    OUT OF STOCK
    $12.99

  • SHELLZONE

    OUT OF STOCK
    $13.50

  • Small

    OUT OF STOCK
    $3.00

  • Medium

    OUT OF STOCK
    $4.00

  • Large

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.00

Daily Specials

  • Breaded Cheese Curds

    $8.25

  • pepperoni roll

    $6.50

  • pasta diablo

    $15.99

  • ultimate cheesesteak pierogies

    $15.99

  • cajun bang bang salmon

    $16.99

  • Mini Sicilian Combo

    $10.74

  • Mini Pizza Combo

    $10.74

  • mini steak & bluec cheese

    OUT OF STOCK
    $14.99

  • philly chz stk salad

    $13.50

  • 1/2 ham & swiss

    $12.50

  • big burger

    $13.99

  • bowl cream of mushroom

    $6.50

  • bowl creamy chivcken noodle

    $6.50

  • cup cream of mushroom

    $5.50

  • cup creamy chicken noodle

    $5.50

NA Beverages

  • 16 oz Bottle

    $2.00

  • 20 oz Bottle

    $2.50

  • 2 LT MT Dew

    $3.50

  • 2 LT Pepsi

    $3.50

  • 2 LT Diet Pepsi

    $3.50

  • 2 LTCherry pepsi

    $3.50

  • 2 LT Ginger ale

    $3.50

  • 20oz Pepsi

    $2.50

  • Bottled Water

    $1.00

  • Can Diet Dew

    $1.25

  • Can Diet Pepsi

    $1.25

  • Can Mt Dew

    $1.25

  • Can Pepsi

    $1.25

  • Red Bull

    $3.50

  • Starbucks Frap

    $3.25

  • Can dr. Pepper

    $1.25

  • Can ginger ale

    $1.25

  • Can root beer

    $1.25

  • Can Coca cola

    $1.25

  • Can Poppi

    $1.75

  • sm gat aids

    $1.25

  • lg gat aids

    $1.75

  • Liquid Ice

    $3.50

  • Gal Diet Iced Tea

    $4.00

  • Gal Reg Iced Tea

    $4.00

  • QRT Black & Gold

    $2.00

  • QRT Diet Iced Tea

    $2.00

  • QRT Reg Iced Tea

    $2.00

  • 1/2 Gal Reg Iced Tea

    $3.00

  • Lemonade

    $1.25

  • Diet Tea

    $1.25

  • Reg Tea

    $1.25

Kids

  • Mac & Cheese

    $6.99

  • Kids Chicken Finger

    $6.99

  • Kids Pasta w/ MB

    $6.99

  • Kid Pizza

    $6.99

  • Kids Burger

    $6.99

  • Kids Rav

    $6.99

  • Kids Grilled Cheese

    $6.99

Desserts

  • Carrot Cake

    $7.99

  • Cheesecake

    $8.99

  • Chocolate Cake

    $7.99

  • Cin Sugar Knots 3

    $3.50

  • Cin Sugar Knots 6

    $5.25

  • Cin Pretzel Bites

    $5.99

  • Funnel Cake Fries

    $7.95

  • funnel cake sundae

    $5.99

  • lemon bliss cheesecake

    $8.99

Sides & Extras

  • 12 oz dressing

    $4.50

  • 3 Garlic Bread

    $2.50

  • 6 Garlic Bread

    $4.50

  • 8 oz dressing

    $3.00

  • add egg

    $1.25

  • Apple sauce

    $4.25

  • Bacon

    $2.00

  • Beef Gravy

    $0.75

  • Cheese Sauce

    $1.99

  • Chicken Gravy

    $0.75

  • Coleslaw

    $4.25

  • Crumbled Bleu

    $1.99

  • Extra bread

    $0.50

  • Extra Chicken Breast

    $5.00

  • Extra cocktail

    $0.75

  • Extra Lg dressing

    $1.05

  • Extra Meat sauce

    $2.00

  • Extra Meatball

    $2.75

  • Extra sauce

    $1.05

  • Extra sausage

    $3.00

  • Extra Shrimp

    $8.00

  • Extra Sm dressing

    $0.75

  • Extra Steak

    $7.00

  • Extra tartar

    $0.75

  • Garlic butter Lg

    $1.05

  • Garlic butter Sm

    $0.75

  • Mac & cheese

    $6.50

  • Mashed

    $4.25

  • Quart of dressing

    $12.00

  • Shredded Cheese

    $1.99

  • Side of pasta

    $6.50

  • Veg of day

    $4.25

Merchandise

Keychain

  • Keychain

    $5.00

T Shirts

  • Womens Medium

    $20.00

  • Womens Large

    $20.00

  • Womens X Large

    OUT OF STOCK
    $20.00

  • Mens Large

    $20.00

  • Mens XLarge

    $20.00

  • Mens XXLarge

    OUT OF STOCK
    $22.00
If you use a credit card, this establishment will charge an additional 2.00% ($0.00) to help offset processing costs. This amount is not more than what this establishment pays in fees.

Mini Special Bleu Sicilian

$14.49

Customize your item

Sauce Choice

Required
Select 1

Sici Mini Toppings

Optional

Pizza Mods

Optional

Dipping Sauce Pizza

Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Shelly Pie Location and Hours

(412) 646-2560
912 PENN AVE, Turtle Creek, PA 15145
Closed • Opens Wednesday at 11AM
View menu
Facebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement